According to a number of industry bloggers, Lexmark is under investigation by both the British Office of Fair Trading and the Trading Standards Institute after a firmware update was released that prevents third party and refilled inkjet cartridges from being used in Lexmark printers.

A number of consumers have reportedly complained to the two advisory bodies after noticing that the latest firmware update for their inkjet printers prevented them from using cartridges that were not Lexmark originals.

However Trading Standards told The Recycler: “we don’t deal with investigations into businesses”, and that it may be the case that a local authority is separately dealing with the complaints against Lexmark.

When contacted, the Office of Fair Trading stated that it does not give out any information about ongoing complaints against companies and Lexmark declined to comment.

This issue has serious implications for the aftermarket – the OEM seems to have made a move towards shutting its printers and cartridges off from remanufactured and refilled cartridges. However, taking this step may also land Lexmark in serious trouble with the British authorities for cutting off its aftermarket competition.

The OEM has been involved in a series of moves that may suggest it is trying to shut out the aftermarket, including patenting an anti-remanufacturing device, and contesting a longlegal trial with Static Control over the past few years.

Samsung has alsobeen criticised for updating its chip technologies in an alleged attempt to block the use of remanufactured cartridges in its printers.

Have you experienced this issue first-hand? If so, please comment.

Our recommendation is that you take this seriously and avoid buying one of these products for the time being.  We have long suspected that this practice has been going on.  It is the only logical way to explain the behaviour of a number of printers rejecting 3rd party cartridges  brought to our attention by customers.

Check out my post of July last year, “Cartridge Alert for Epson Printers“

Most of our Epson customers use them.  Cartridges of this type are able to contain a little under 20ml of ink.  A year ago we noticed that they only contained 14ml and recently only 7.4ml in the black and 5.5 in the colour.

This means that Epson has been stealthily increasing the price of these cartridges without you noticing by reducing the amount of ink.  Typically they cost around £12 each.  Compare this to ours containing 19ml at £5 and you can see just how much you are being ripped off.

The answer is a lot!  However did you know that the cost can vary greatly for the same printer?  In another post I suggested that using the XL type cartridge if you can would save money.  Here is the shocking truth.  HP produce great products and they are the leaders in terms of inkjet market share so why produce 2 different cartridges for the same printer, don’t they make enough money already.  The 350 cartridge costs £14 on their website.  It contains only 4ml of ink so each ml costs you £3.50p !  The 350XL will aslo work in the same printer and it costs £29 for 25ml of ink so each ml costs you £1.16p.  That is quite a difference, £3.50 vs £1.16!  Other manufacturers are also doing this.

I think I know which one I would purchase.

Nextlife are a range of remanufactured cartridges for 70% of HP, Canon, Epson, Lexmark and their own Dell printers. Their marketing material claims that you can save ‘up to’ 20% and print ‘up to’ 20% more when compared to branded cartridges.

Granted the packaging is made from 50% post consumer waste and is 100% recyclable but the ‘up to’ is just legal speak for ‘may not be as much as 20%’.
This approach is more environmentally friendly than purchasing new cartridges every time but…..
why would you use this product instead of the multitude of much cheaper, reliable products that have been available for years?

Get this, Dell printer owners. You purchase your dell printer cartridge, on-line as you can’t get them in the shops, then when it is empty you send it back to Dell. They then refill it and sell it back to you for only ‘up to’ 20% less than the price you have already paid for it. Sounds like money for old rope to me.

I wonder what Lexmark have to say about this bearing in mind that they manufacture Dell inkjet printers and the cartridges !

That’s just how it is for printers.

How do they sell a really good all in one device for £40?

Where do they make a profit?

On rip-off cartridges of course.

Please don’t be mislead by enticing sales material.

Call us before you make a decision.

Even if you don’t purchase one of our printers we’ll happily advise you on what to avoid and what’s good.

Beware, as a rule of thumb the supposedly ‘cheap’ printers on the market cost the most to run!

Don’t consider anything with a page cost of over 2p for monochrome.